WRITTEN BYJamal Akbar Alam
· 3 min read

When a website template is the right call (and when it isn't)

READING NOTES06 / 23

I build custom sites for a living, so you'd expect me to tell you templates are a trap. They aren't. Plenty of businesses should use one, and I'd rather say so than sell you a build you don't need.

The mistake isn't using a template. It's using one without knowing what it costs you later.

When a template is the right call

You're testing an idea. If you don't yet know whether anyone wants what you sell, a site that exists this week beats a beautiful one that exists in two months. Spend the money on finding out.

Your site has one job and it's simple. A name, a few services, a phone number, a contact form. If the page doesn't need to do anything clever, a template does it fine.

You'll edit it yourself, often. Website builders are good at this. If your team changes prices on Tuesdays and you don't want to ask anyone, a builder with a friendly editor may serve you better than a custom build.

It has a short life. An event, a campaign, a one-season promotion. Don't build something permanent for something temporary.

The budget is the budget. A good template site is better than no site, and much better than a custom site you can't finish paying for.

When it stops working

Your brand is part of the product. If people choose you partly because of how you look and feel, a template that looks like a thousand others works against you.

You need something it doesn't do. Custom booking logic, a particular checkout flow, an integration with how your business actually runs. Past a certain point you're fighting the template, and plugins and workarounds add weight and risk.

It's slow and you can't fix it. Template sites often load code for features you never use. If speed matters, because you pay for ads or sell on phones, that overhead is a real cost.

You've outgrown the structure. The sign is a sentence like "we'd love to do X but the site can't." That's a template talking.

The test I'd use

Write down what the site must do in one sentence. Then ask two questions:

  1. Can a template do exactly that, without workarounds?
  2. In a year, will I still want only that?

Two yeses: use a template, and be happy about it. A no on either: it's worth a conversation about something custom.

What I'd still check on a template

  • Ownership. Can you export your content and move if you leave the platform?
  • Speed on a phone. Open the demo on a mid-range device, not on your laptop.
  • The real cost. Subscription, paid apps and plugins, and your own time, over a year, not just month one.

Where I come in

If a template fits, I'll tell you. If you've outgrown one, or your brand needs something specific, a custom site from me starts at $900 for a small business, and the business website page lists what's included. If you're stuck between a few platforms, Shopify vs. WordPress walks through the trade-offs, and the cost guide helps you compare first-year totals.

Not sure which camp you're in? Send me your site or your idea and I'll give you a straight answer.

Have something in mind?

Let’s talk